Learning Your Roles: How to be a Composer and a Conductor in the Classroom

In my early years as a teacher, there were times that I measured my success by how clean my hands were at the end of the day. I knew I had a rough day when I lost my whiteboard eraser and, in the interest of the lesson, I used my hands to erase the board. Those were the dark ages.

Today, I’m in my sixth year teaching. During those six years, I have taught all of middle school math, and I have been an Algebra I teacher at Sci Academy for the last three and a half years. During my transition from “rookie math teacher” to sixth-year teacher, I’ve relied on a few major guiding principles that have shaped my development.

*Failure is an accelerant to change. *Seek out those who know more than you. *Work really, really hard. *Find a thought partner. *Get a dog (My dog’s name is Frank – he’s great). *Keep reading teacher training books (Top picks: Tools for Teaching, Teach Like A Champion) *Most importantly: know your roles.

The shift that had the biggest impact on the performance of my students and my own satisfaction as a teacher was when I began to recognize the roles I play in the classroom. This recognition came when I realized that teachers don’t just “wear many hats,” as the saying goes. Instead, they must master two very specific roles:

1. The Composer: Plan, and then respond to academic data.

I could be wrong, but I feel like most teachers I know tend to hit the ground running as composers. Upon learning about backwards design, five-step lessons, and data driven instruction, they see some sort of light and get sucked in. I know I did.

As a rookie teacher, I flourished in the role of the composer. I shined in my ability to use data to drive instruction, create interim assessments, build out scopes and sequences, design meaningful classwork, and respond to data by re-teaching, tutoring, spiraling content, and modifying classwork.

As time passed, I realized something was missing, although I didn’t immediately know what or why. I’d look at my data tracker and continuously see red (literally, it’s the color we use to note objectives that kids have not yet mastered). Tech-inclined and armed with spreadsheets, I sought out patterns in the data. None emerged! One of my top performers, who routinely scored a 100%, bombed this objective while a scholar who struggled all year nailed it. Looking at student work, I couldn’t glean any misconceptions or major errors that would have predicted such scores.

Suddenly, it clicked. I realized that while my data tracker captured mastery data, it illuminated very little about what went on during class with my actual kids. I had been relying on my skills as a composer, but I completely missed one critical component of being a teacher: emotional data. I realized that I had been neglecting to look at kid-level data, the thing that is beneath all of the content gaps and misconceptions that go into teaching and learning.

2. The Conductor: Watch, listen, and then respond to the kids (emotional data).

I’m no magician. Inevitably, there are times when kids walk into class grumpy, excited, lethargic, timid, emotionally tenuous, or feeling like they’re on top of the world. To better prepare kids for their futures, I realized it was crucial to acknowledge and respond to this emotional data: to view myself as the conductor of my classroom.

Prior to class, I’d compose my curriculum and lesson materials that I planned to work through with my kids. During class, though, it was time to play into my second role as a conductor – using finesse and presence to coach kids to the emotional state that best fits learning: happy, productive, hardworking. Here are a few examples of what this looks like in practice in my room:

Weak eye contact at threshold? Fist-bump, a you okay statement and follow up later, ideally when that scholar is doing the right thing.

Poor posture during the do now? Circulate, praise for correct work, remind scholar of the expectations, then move on.
Kids sharing excitement and positivity about content and class? Assign points to the class for enthusiasm, spotlight or shout out an individual.

Scholar takes a risk and gets a question wrong? Halt the class, recognize effort, and come back to them for the next question.
Class feeling unsuccessful due to challenging work? Talk aspirations and get kids excited about where they’re headed. Remind kids that they can do this, and manufacture small, content aligned tasks that generate positive energy and momentum.

As a teacher, you don’t wear hats. Instead, you play two specific roles. Teaching is hard. The roles of conductor and composer are intertwined – you can’t just take one on and ignore the other. You could compose the most beautiful lesson imaginable, but, without skill in conducting, that lesson could sound shrill and off-beat. On the other hand, you could be a top-notch conductor, but, without an excellent score, your kids could be off-track toward their end of year goals. An educator plans and responds to academic data, all the while watching, listening, and responding to their kids.

Evan Stoudt teaches Algebra I to freshmen at Sci Academy. For the last three years, Evan’s students have earned top scores in the school district. This year, Evan is piloting blended learning strategies in his classroom by infusing video instruction and online resources to the dynamic CA Algebra I curriculum. In addition to teaching, Evan serves as Freshman Dean at Sci Academy, where he supports teachers, advisors, and scholars to develop and maintain a positive, challenging, and joyous academic experience. He earned a Bachelor’s degree in Marketing from Loyola University of New Orleans in 2009.

Related Posts

Collegiate celebrates Black History Month

The lights in the Livingston gymnasium are low. The stage curtain is still drawn. A hush falls over the crowd of 400 students as the sound of their peers’ voices come booming through the sound system. Th…

Summer Food Service Program

News Release Open Sites
The RSD-Collegiate Academies is participating in the Summer Food Service Program. Meals will be provided to all
eligible children without charge. Acceptance and participating requ…

Bianca Benton Teacher Feature May 2019

Bianca Benton, English teacher at Collegiate Baton Rouge, is the fourth and final Teacher Feature of the 2018-2019 school year. Congratulations, Bianca! Thank you for the growth, ownership, and joy you…

Juan Serrano Teacher Feature 18-19

“It’s not about you. It’s not about me. It’s about the people we work for and the people we work with.”

Juan Serrano, social studies teacher at Abramson Sci Academy, is the first Teacher Feature of th…

D'Andrea Jenkins Teacher Feature 17-18

D’Andrea Jenkins, Science teacher at Collegiate Baton Rouge, is the fourth Teacher Feature of the 2017-2018 school year. D’Andrea thinks outside the box to create an extremely challenging and extremely e…

Eric Parrie Teacher Feature 16-17

Eric Parrie, a Social Studies Teacher at George Washington Carver High School, is the third Collegiate Academies’ Teacher Feature for the 2016-2017 school year. Eric is a larger than life character engag…

Victor Jones Teacher Feature 16-17

Victor Jones, English Teacher at George Washington Carver Collegiate, is the second Teacher Feature of the 2016-2017 school year. Victor uses his big personality and bigger vision to support his students…

Leah Lykins Teacher Feature 16-17

Leah Lykins, AP Environmental Science Teacher at Abramson Sci Academy, is the first Teacher Feature of the 2016-2017 school year. Leah empowers her students to engage with their data in deep, meaningful…

Sara Mich Teacher Feature 15-16

Sara Mich, a Sci Academy English Teacher, is the first Teacher Feature of the 2015-2016 school year. Sara’s strong focus on constant personal and scholar growth creates a classroom where students achieve…

Phil Gallia Teacher Feature 15-16

Phil Galia, US History teacher at Carver Collegiate, is the second Teacher Feature of the 2015-2016 school year. In class, Phil supports his scholars in forming and expressing their own opinions, while a…

Ben Ifshin Teacher Feature 15-16

Ben Ifshin, one of Sci Academy’s Biology teachers, is the third and final Teacher Feature of the 2015-2016 school year. Ben Ifshin’s class has a deep empathy for student experience, combining joy with su…

The Season for Gratitude

Our scholars (really, all high school kids) need intense academic preparation to be college-ready. From phonics and pre-Algebra to AP Literature and Calculus, the intellectual work of moving from middle…

What We Can Learn From Singapore

In the past several decades, Singapore has rapidly climbed up the international education totem pole. According to the George Lucas Educational Foundation, Singapore’s schools have developed a reputation…

Scholars’ Families Join the CA Team

This summer, I had the great pleasure of sitting down for an interview with Lakethia Hampton, the aunt of one of the girls on the Sci Academy volleyball team. Having coached volleyball for the past four…

Smart Cities: New Orleans

The first Maker Faire in New Orleans was held over the weened. It was hosted by a new school incubated by 4.0 Schools and New Schools New Orleans (NSNO)– Bricolage Academy. Matt Candler, founder of 4.0…